Elon Musk’s influence is global but its epicentre lies in the United States. A country where opinions often pass from generation to generation and middle grounds are rare to find. A land where despite how lovely the people can be, a balanced opinion could see you a potential enemy to whomever you speak.
Having travelled much of the country on foot and interacted with people from all walks of life, I know that asking Americans why they hold certain views can at times feel as futile as asking someone in Glasgow why they support the monarchy, only to get the response: ‘I’m a Ranger’s fan’. According to a national NBC News poll, opinion on Musk is split almost entirely down the middle and it is divided by politics. To put it simply he is often loved by Republicans and loathed by Democrats.
To some he is a billionaire megalomaniac, to others a messiah of free speech. Is he a genius advancing society in which the government should move out of the way? Elon Musk certainly thinks so.
This would explain why on 5 October 2024, while United States Republican nominee Donald J. Trump returned to a rally at the exact site where the attempt on his life took place back in July, Elon Musk opted to join him on stage. Talk of Trump offering Musk a position in Government in return for his support had been rumoured, and has since been confirmed as Musk has been appointed head of the newly created ‘Department of Government Efficiency’ which aims to cut governmental bureaucracy and waste. Musk has publicly spoken out about government involvement in social media and his position close to the newly elected President will likely allow him more sway over how the government handles his private sector endeavours, including his social media platform ‘X’ (previously Twitter).
Even fellow social media mogul Mark Zuckerberg, who respectably keeps his hands relatively clean of politics, has spoken out about his displeasure at the government putting pressure on Facebook to censor certain information during the covid-19 pandemic. Looking closer to home our very own emigrant billionaire Andrew Carnegie believed the government should stay out of how he ran his steel empire and aimed to guide politics with his wealth and influence, until later having a change of heart, turning from politics and choosing to influence the world through philanthropy.
Until now I had been a passive consumer of information on Elon Musk, taking notice only when he had achieved something prophesied in a science fiction novel. Reusable rockets, electric autonomous cars, online payments, global connection through Starlink, and Neuralink tethering brains to computers – the long list of world changing projects he’s been involved in is undeniable.
In years gone by, those who disliked Musk would cite staff complaints of being worked excessively hard. However, I grew up seeing the rise of Apple and Microsoft. The tyranny of Bill Gates and Steve Jobs were legendary, not just in the Silicon Valley where Musk made his bones, but around the world. Hard work under ruthless visionary CEOs is the price you pay to be at the forefront of any industry, especially the fast paced, competitive tech industry. A previous employee, Tom Moline spoke out against SpaceX. He publicly claimed the company’s management mantra to be ‘(the) ends justifies the means.’ I tend to agree.
That said, Musk’s new, more direct relationship with politics marks a shift. Billionaires being involved in politics is not new, but Musk’s control over what the approximate 611 million monthly users see on his social media platform ‘X’ is slightly different to what we have seen before, although not as groundbreaking or shocking as it is being perceived.
Social media and information can swing elections. The use of big data has been revolutionary since Dan Wagner used it to target voters for the Obama Administration.
Information is in many ways the most dangerous weaponry. Musk has been accused of wielding this weaponry to place Trump in office. Musk’s idea of what he refers to as a digital town square is admirable. The problem is that ‘X’ is his town square and he has been accused of giving his friends megaphones.
After starting multiple twitter accounts to test these accusations in the run up to the election, there does appear to be some truth in the claims; posts appeared from Musk and Trump on the ‘For you’ page despite not following either. The first post was Musk’s – a video of his starship booster being plucked out of mid-air by robotic arms. (At least his engineering interests do not appear to have taken a backburner). The fourth – Trump at a rally.
Journalism teaches us that there is bias in all information and it can be perpetuated, not despite a journalist’s impartiality but because of it. It is the role of the journalist to use their experience and understanding of what they are writing about (what some would refer to as bias) to take information then compile that to create something that comes as close to an accurate truth as possible. Bias exists in everything and social media, the same as traditional forms of media, will always reflect the views of its owner.
I understand the outrage. When we read other forms of media, the likes owned by Murdoch, Rothermere and Barclay, we are wise to the political tendencies. When ‘X’ appears to peddle posts which Elon Musk takes an interest in, we have been a little bit less aware. But no longer.
Ideally those with powers of mass information dissemination would show no clear political allegiances, eventually stepping down from their role of servitude to truth and balance before announcing to the shock of the world their political affiliations. Much like John Bercow did after his time as Speaker in the House of Commons.
But this is just an ideal, and social media platforms don’t work like this. Musk’s ‘X’ is no different from other media outlets. It reflects the views and whims of its owner.
For now, Elon Musk’s role at the head of ‘X’ raises hard questions about the future of information and influence. As he wields unprecedented power over public discourse, we must consider what it means for democracy. Are we happy with our digital ‘town squares’ reflecting the biases and interests of their owners? Should platforms like ‘X’ be held to higher forms of neutrality? As consumers of information we must remain vigilant in our interactions with the narratives we encounter. The digital town square is something to strive for, as complicated and unattainable as the theory of democracy. And who knows, as Andrew Carnegie once saw the light and turned from meddling in politics to philanthropy, still too could Elon Musk.

