Political Satire: Can It Survive?

By Jonathan Scobie

In an age of absurd politics and politicians, how effective can satire be when the punchline comes before the joke?

Political satire is the art of exaggerating reality to expose the contradictions or failures of those in power. In the UK, it has been a cornerstone of political media for decades. Yet in 2022, reality did what satire couldn’t: a 60p Tesco iceberg lettuce was livestreamed by the Daily Star to see if it would outlast Liz Truss’ premiership. It did. Truss resigned after 49 days in office, while the lettuce was launched to stardom. Indeed, the stunt was so impactful that the British Film Institute’s national archive acquired the footage.

The reason this joke worked so well was because there was no exaggeration. With the absurdity already there, a key question is asked: what happens when reality is funnier than the joke?

Traditionally, the satire process begins with politicians claiming to be competent, with the voters trusting them with the power to run the country. Subsequently, when the politicians display incompetence, the satirist exaggerates their flaws for comedic effect. This allows the viewer to see an obvious contradiction: the politician is claiming to be responsible, trustworthy and capable, yet is behaving otherwise. Satire makes this contradiction more digestible and entertaining, thus giving satire a political function.

However, politicians increasingly provide their own absurdity. Whilst the satirist can still exaggerate their behaviour, it isn’t really necessary. This is because reality has caught up with the comedic exaggeration of satire and the difference is thus blurred. If reality itself is ridiculous the contradiction is right in front of us. This makes the audience accustomed to absurdity. Therefore, satire is losing the power it used to wield. Why do we need to illustrate the ridiculousness of an action when the actions are already ridiculous?

The examples of absurd incompetency are enormous. The incessant squabbling, changeover of power and crises of the Brexit years presented like a soap opera. Satirists don’t even need to pick up their pen for certain images: Boris Johnson shouting and flapping British flags around while dangling from a zipline. Or politicians being photographed during the COVID-19 lockdown breaching restrictions by having huge parties, while Britons couldn’t see their loved ones. With our politicians providing this extraordinary imagery the bar has been lowered for the public, and satire loses its importance. The only way they cope is to try to laugh off reality.

This normalisation of crises caused by our politicians causes incredible problems for society. Author Malcolm Gladwell calls it the “satire paradox.” The more someone finds a problem funny the less they are changed by it. They think about the punchline more than the horrific consequences and what should be outrage is replaced by laughter. This becomes ten times worse when reality is the punchline and not just the political satire.

Perhaps satire hasn’t become weaker, but politicians have just become more aware of using it themselves. Boris Johnson, as a host of Have I Got News for You, knew exactly how to perpetuate his own satire. The self-deprecation and bumbling persona allowed him to be part of the joke and not just the butt of it. This made it near impossible for satirists to criticise him and have the joke stick as he just would lean into the absurdity, reframing the joke. Instead of the public laughing at him we were laughing with him.

So, with the everchanging political reality, satire will need to find a new use. Instead of exaggerating contradictions that are blatantly obvious, it should be used to contextualise incompetency and preserve it for the public memory. The lettuce was funny because it made the absurdity of the Truss’ premiership instantly recognisable. Remembering the lettuce allows us to remember the scandal. Satire can survive if instead of making scandals entertainment; the consequences of the politicians’ actions are made easier for the viewer to digest, discuss and not forget about.  

Author

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More articles
Scroll to Top
Skip to content