Some people use them as a stepping stone. Others believe they steal from the theater. Can theatrical bootlegs be a doorway to the stage or are they an act of betrayal against it?
Anyone familiar with the world of theatre TikTok will likely have noticed a strange term being used called slime tutorials. No one is sitting in a kitchen with a bowl of glue. It is simply a coded name for circumventing moderation to post videos taken during live performances by those in the audience. These videos garner millions of views and thus the controversy surrounding these videos have reached similar levels.
It is very expensive to go to the theatre. Even in Glasgow, with large touring productions coming into the city via the King’s Theatre and the Theatre Royal, it costs more than a week’s worth of groceries to buy a good seat to watch a musical. Students who are living on loan payments and working part time jobs cannot afford this expense. Disability, location and caregiving responsibilities make even attempts of going to these theatres as difficult as trying to get to Mars.
Bootleg supporters say that they provide access. Fans in Inverness watching a low quality video of a show they will never be able to attend live are not customers these theaters will be regularly missing. Many fans find themselves purchasing tickets when they fall in love with a show via a poor quality video made on someone’s phone. Musicals have a streamed soundtrack and no one claims that it hurts box office sales, so why should it be any different for videos? Furthermore, there are many productions that are never officially recorded, leaving fan-made recordings all that’s left of the show, visually.
There is also a community aspect to bootlegs. Fan clubs based on bootlegs share recommendations, exchange trivia about shows and introduce one another to smaller productions. For young people who feel disconnected from school, discovering others who have the same interests can sometimes be a way of connecting and escaping from their troubles even momentarily.
However, theatre is not a commodity that can be duplicated and sold. Every performance is created by actors, musicians, designers and crew members. Filming it without their consent is stealing months of their work and dedication to their craft, and all but a handful of venues ban the recording of performances in their terms of entry. Recording without consent can infringe upon copyright laws which could lead to both the theatre and the person recording having to deal with legalities.
Not only does filming distract actors while performing a scene and pulls audiences out of the story they paid to experience, actors have also expressed their concern of having an off night or a misstep that they will be judged by for eternity and that will be taken completely out of context. The ephemeral nature of live theatre is its most valuable attribute. Bootlegging removes that without anyone granting permission to do so.
There are also financial considerations at hand as the theatre operates on thin profit margins. Independent theaters in Glasgow and small college theatrical productions know this all too well. Each ticket represents revenue for both types of organisations.
As mentioned above, in the United Kingdom, it is essentially already illegal. However, policing numerous cellphones throughout hundreds of performances is nearly unfeasible and issuing penalties such as searching bags before entering a venue or ejecting patrons for filming during a performance will ruin the evening for everybody else attending. Any venue knows however that enforcing a complete prohibition on every patron using their camera is something that it cannot achieve.
The true question, though, should be: why does demand for such products exist in the first place? Bootlegs may represent symptoms of an unmet desire within audiences for some type of access to theatre experiences. Potential solutions may lie in offering official filmed versions of productions available for streaming such as The National Theatre Online subscription, in-person movie screenings of productions, and affordable options for students to see professional productions.
While both parties have valid arguments, bootleggers believe that theatre is too inaccessible and performers believe that access does not equate permission to record. Strict laws will not curb demand. If only theatre was offered at prices that more people could afford and was made accessible to more people then perhaps the demand for bootlegged content would decrease.
For years now, theatre companies have been telling fans to put their phones away. Perhaps instead, maybe we should start asking what they were looking for in the first place.

