Are theatres relying on relevant faces to gain audiences, or do their performances warrant the stage?
Recently it appears every major theatre production has a famous face attached to dominating billboards: from Hollywood scion North West being handed the role of Simba in the Hollywood Bowl’s The Lion King, to Rachel Zegler serenading the streets of Soho as Evita. This begs the question: are theatres relying on relevant faces to gain audiences, or do their performances warrant the stage?
It would be lying to claim theatres don’t benefit from the attention of big ticket names; last year the West End’s box office produced over £1bn in revenue, its highest recorded. Clearly, stunt casting influences non-theatre regulars into seeing shows. The West End’s Cabaret frequently says ‘Willkommen’ to new celebrities with every change of cast. It appears that the Kit Kat Club is quite exclusive, sporting patrons such as nepo baby Maude Apatow and Vogue covergirl Cara Delevingne to childhood West End star Layton Williams. Did Apatow or Delevingne get the gig from genuine talent? Is meritocracy still alive in the arts? Or did Apatow’s clout from the hit show Euphoria (2019–2026), or, moreover, did family connections get her the role? Similarly, did Delevingne’s status as a muse and supermodel transfix the casting directors? The role that both Apatow and Delevingne took on was that of Sally Bowles, a second rate chanteuse, so it would make sense that the actors need not be drama school alumni, but just because they can do the role does that mean they should? Out of the many professional performers that have studied their craft at leading conservatoires, it could feel like a kick in the teeth for some already famous model, screen actor, singer, or even just some celebrities kid, to come along for a short stint in the theatre – the gritty land of real actors – to prove their worthiness of acclaim or simply to put their fans in the stalls. However, this does not mean that these celebrities are necessarily bad performers. It just questions why they were cast as opposed to seasoned thespians solely because of their influence. Would you rather see a show with a famed face yet adequate performance, or a true professional who has honed the skills and experience required to provide a phenomenal experience?
It’s true that theatres have always cast big stars for leading roles, but these people are cast on merit and become household names in theatre, they are not exploited as a media stunt to sell tickets. Nevertheless I can’t totally slate Cabaret, there have been powerhouse performers like previously mentioned Layton Williams, an Olivier winner who has performed in the West End since the age of twelve. So, when you see a celebrity like Williams advertised to be in a show, it’s likely to be outstanding. Theatre stars have earned their place, so when they are in a show their fans come also, does this take away from the show or other performers? Recently Broadway royalty Leslie Odom Jr. returned to his career defining role as Aaron Burr in London. This isn’t stunt casting like discussed previously, it is a form of fan service, because he is not just some famous face stepping into a role for marketing, he shaped the role of Burr and was part of making Hamilton the era defining show it is today. It may have distracted from the cast, but is it not an honour to work with a legend like the original Burr? Hamilton has gained a dedicated fan base over the decade through being recorded for streaming services and every Hamilton fan recognizes Odom Jr. as Burr, its meta, so maybe it isn’t distracting from the show like other circumstances because to the audience he fulfills their vision of Hamilton.
Besides musicals, famous actors are also tackling plays. Dramas don’t give the luxury of so-so performances being supported by ensembles, catchy songs and pyrotechnics. So famous actors that get cast are more often than not worth their salt, with the likes of Gillian Anderson in Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf? and Sadie Sink in Romeo and Juliet. Their fans – especially Sink’s who are younger – are flocking to plays they wouldn’t otherwise. Shakespeare is renownedly abhorred from one English class to another as Shakespeare’s texts can be a labyrinth for those unfamiliar, it takes time that people don’t give after their high school teacher bored them to tears reading Hamlet in monotone verse. But with celebrities like Sink involved, the Bard is selling out, and now people are enjoying Shakespeare while culturing themselves further.
On the other hand there is the downfall of ticket pricing, for Anderson’s performance of Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?, the near three month run is almost sold out despite the odd ticket for a Wednesday matinee going for as much as £175. Casting celebrities both ramps up production costs and demand for the performance, hence ticket costs skyrocketing, pricing people out. If stunt casting continues to have these effects on who can afford to see a show, does the theatre just become an overpriced zoo for the well off public to gawk at their favourite actors?
Celebrities have been and always will be cast in theatre, it is a facet of their work. However, whilst at times it is obviously a cheap attempt at attracting audiences, if the actor is genuinely the right call for the role and is giving an outstanding performance then what more could you want? It is a shame to not see equally talented performers without cultural leverage be overlooked, but the industry has always favoured those well connected. Nevertheless, can’t it also be slightly exhilarating and reality shattering – however parasocial – to see a celebrity in the flesh? The problem lies in shows being held in a higher regard solely due to its casts IMDb. If ticket prices remained the same regardless of how star-studded the playbill is, then stunt casting only helps draw in audiences allowing them the chance to experience theatre, and hopefully return, famous cast or not.

