Why traditional poetic conventions may not be necessary in the modern literary landscape
Through social media, it has never been easier to create art online for the world to see. Anyone, no matter their knowledge of poetic traditions, can write whatever comes into their head in their notes app, between shifts or classes, post it on Instagram, and get thousands of eyes on their work. Contemporary poetry often aims to be experimental and create something new to express the unique issues and feelings which arise in the modern world. As a result, poetry now is most commonly written in free verse (meaning it has no set pattern of rhyme or metre), as its lack of rules and convention suit new and innovative styles and ideas, such as allowing the poem to be laid out in a certain shape on the page, or to portray a more personal and conversational tone.
However, for most of poetic history in the English language, traditional poetry, with a reliance on rhyme and metre, has been the norm. This raises the question: are conventions of form in poetry necessary, or does free verse better represent poetry as an idiosyncratic, intimate, creative mode of expression?
Once upon a time, rhyme and metre served an important purpose in everyday life. As an integral part of information learning and storytelling passed on from person to person, especially important when only a small percentage of the population were literate. Poetry as a craft emerged from this integral oral tradition, with ballads and epics often exploring early ideas of democracy and protest. But this doesn’t mean that poets should stay within the shackles of convention forever. Creativity and expression are, to many, the entire purpose of poetry, and at a certain point, staying strictly within tradition and convention can only hinder these endeavours.
Free verse poetry appeared as a new movement towards the end of the 19th century, with revered American poet Walt Whitman, and continued to flourish into the mid 20th century. The idea that poetry should be freed from restrictions of form was not a new one by any means. In an introductory note to his Paradise Lost, the 17th century poet John Milton states that his contemporaries became “carried away by Custom, but much to their own vexation, hindrance, and constraint to express many things otherwise, and for the most part worse then else they would have exprest them”. Milton’s comments here hold true hundreds of years later. Poetic form can and often does restrict creativity and expression, and so free verse, being liberated from these restrictions, is a positive direction for contemporary poetry to continue to travel in.
In the 1980s, a new generation of poets emerged who had grown tired of free verse’s popularity, and began exploring and writing in traditional forms again, using structure, rhyme, metre, and regularity. This return to convention was termed “New Formalism”. Poets writing in this movement had grown tired of the confessional and emotionally intimate style of free verse, and so returned to the traditional poetic forms and conventions. New Formalism was criticised by proponents and writers of free verse as a kind of regression, rather than anything new or original. Some even argued that the movement was oppressive and elitist, and whilst this is maybe a more extreme view of New Formalism, it is not hard to imagine how it could be interpreted this way.
Surely there is so much more room for imagination and creativity when there are no rules, and writing can be a free and unrestricted experience. Of course, free verse and other non-traditional poetry shouldn’t be completely void of poetic skill or technique, but by relying too heavily on rhyme and metre, almost like stabilisers on a bike, means that an idea or subject matter may feel impersonal and not live up to its full potential without true creative freedom.
Langston Hughs’ “I, Too”, is a great example of successful free verse. Taking inspiration from Whitman’s “I Hear America Singing”, Hughs writes about his own experience of America, using repetition, and thoughtful use of line length and structure to accentuate his subject matter and the emotion behind the poem. The poet does this without reliance on metre and rhyme, which allows him to have more authority over both his word choice and presentation of the words on the page, and create a more intimate poem.
More recently, the style of free verse poetry which has become popular on social media, particularly Instagram and Tumblr, has been termed “Instapoetry”. It has been criticised heavily for being nonsensical, unpolished, shallow, unoriginal: being written only to look aesthetically pleasing on a poet’s instagram grid. Rupi Kaur, the most popular “Instapoet” has been particularly scrutinised. Nonetheless, she has gained notoriety in online and literary spaces, whether this is due to her poetic skill, or lack of it, is up to personal taste. One clear positive of Instapoetry is that it is boosting poetry’s popularity significantly, allowing more people than ever to have access to creative writing.
By no means is all contemporary poetry written in the Instapoetry style. Ocean Vuong is one of the most critically acclaimed modern poets still writing today, whose style is anything but shallow. In his two very successful poetry collections Night Sky With Exit Wounds and Time is a Mother, Vuong writes in beautiful lyrical free verse about personal and intimate topics such as the immigrant experience, familial relationships, queerness and sexuality. In an interview with the Louisiana Channel, the poet states: “When something is categorised it is easier to manage, right, categorisation is a managerial venture, and I think we lose so much of ourselves in that”. Poetic structure, including rhyme and metre, is a large part of this categorisation which Vuong is against, as it allows work to be categorised more easily, limiting a poets’ work and losing a sense of personality and originality.
Conventional forms of poetry are “categories” which have control over art and our expression. Perhaps, even the category of free verse is still too restrictive. It is a wide category yes, but it still has parameters, something can be free verse or not free verse. Perhaps, it is time to do away with all categories in poetry. Let poetry just exist as poetry, free and inclusive and liberated.
Free verse and other unconventional poetry, when written thoughtfully and skillfully – as can be seen in the work of great poets like Walt Whitman, Langston Hughs and Mary Oliver – is often even more poignant and effective than conventional poetry. Whilst restriction can be great to get the creative juices flowing and help a poet stick to a tried-and-true method for success, poetry is a concentrated and personal form of creative art which better suits individual freedom of expression unfettered by convention.

