Records reveal that changes to prevent incorrect degree calculations and improve student support fell behind schedule.
A reform intended to prevent incorrect degree outcomes at the University of Glasgow was delayed by six months, records obtained by The Glasgow Guardian reveal.
The change forms part of Project Compass, the University’s response to a review prompted by the death of Geography student Ethan Brown. Brown died by suicide on 13 December 2024 after being wrongly told he could not graduate. An internal investigation subsequently found that he should have been awarded a 2:1.
The Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education (QAA) investigated the University’s wider systems, rather than Brown’s individual circumstances. Its January report identified “systemic risks” to academic standards and the student experience, issuing 21 recommendations covering assessment, support, and communication.
The delayed reform involves replacing local degree calculation spreadsheets with a central University-wide tool. A progress tracker dated 20 August, released under a Freedom of Information request, shows that the deadline moved from May to November.
The FOI response also acknowledged that not all calculation tools had been formally validated before use in the 2025-26 exam boards. The University said it had instead strengthened controls and checks of outcomes. Its ongoing review had so far found no degree classification errors, subject to remaining validation.
Reforms to help students understand assessment decisions and how to access support also fell behind schedule. Analysis of the tracker shows that five of nine dated milestones in this area originally due by July had been postponed.
The publication of clearer assessment guidance moved from June to September, while compassionate communication training materials and online resources for staff were pushed back from July to August.
The University attributed the training delays to aligning the materials with the academic calendar. It said the assessment guidance delay would cause no issue provided it was delivered in time for 2026-27.
Some changes have been completed. In an August response to The Glasgow Guardian, the Project Compass team said revised award letters had been finalised and made mandatory for 2026-27.
Developed with students, the letters include clearer next steps and information about support for those receiving potentially difficult academic decisions. The team acknowledged that previous letters varied significantly across Schools and did not always explain what students could do next or where to turn for help.
UNISON branch chair Sophie Watson said staff were struggling to meet demands with existing staffing levels and the speed of change. She warned that high workloads were making it harder to support students effectively.
SRC Vice President Education Ben Jones described progress as “atypically fast” compared with previous University policy changes. He said a very small number of students had approached the SRC about incorrect course results on MyCampus, which it helped resolve quickly.
QAA told The Glasgow Guardian on 21 August that none of its recommendations had been signed off as complete.
“While work to address the recommendations is ongoing, the systemic risks identified in the Targeted Peer Review report remain.”
For any students struggling with mental health, please contact the Samaritans at 0330 094 5717.

