The motivations behind changing place names and how it can be a tool of the powerful.
On 27 August, Trump renamed ‘Lake Ontario’ to ‘Lake America’, a move with few practical impacts, but one rife with symbolism.
While some major companies, such as Apple and Google, have changed the name on their map services (‘Lake America’ for US users, and ‘Lake Ontario (Lake America)’ for others), many, such as MapQuest, have simply refused to make any changes whatsoever. The importance of this executive order therefore lies not in any practical impacts, but in what it represents: the continuation of several worrying patterns in American politics.
Many will have noticed that this order came only six days after trade talks between the US and Canada collapsed, with both sides claiming that the other made 11th-hour changes to the agreement. As a result, Trump had already announced new 50% tariffs on Canada, kickstarting a trade war that is already deeply unpopular with both Canadians and Americans. As per usual, it seems that the President, when not getting what he wants, chooses the most provocative response.
As put by Reuben Rose-Redwood (a Canadian expert in human geography and place-naming studies), renaming Lake Ontario is merely an attempt to “rage-bait a U.S. ally into submission.” A very similar thing was done when changing the ‘Gulf of Mexico’ to the ‘Gulf of America’. It is meant to provoke anger and create discourse among individuals, while also sending a message to the international community. Derek Alderman described this as a move “to exert some advantage or strength in the trade war with Canada.” Alongside Trump’s regular threats to make Canada the ‘51st state’, this projects a starkly non-cooperative and even authoritarian image to the rest of the world.
At both a national and international level, this also demonstrates Trump’s power as an Executive. Since his electoral win in 2024, we have seen him take advantage of the executive order, creating policies without any political pushback. This is no exception. Rose-Redwood pointed out how naming of this type would usually require the involvement of both countries involved, with an extensive consultation. Instead, all this took was one executive order.
Even more recently, we have seen the US being the only country to reject the ‘Equal Earth Projection’ map at the UN, which shows countries with more accurate sizing. Notably, this projection shows Africa as much larger than on the currently used Mercator map. Combined with this new stint of renaming places at a purely national level, should there be fear that the American map now more closely resembles ideology than reality? And should Presidential power be able to shape a truth that is otherwise agreed upon internationally?
Lake Ontario’s name dates back at least 400 years, from an Iroquoian word given to it by the Wendat people, meaning ‘Great Lake’. It was given by a group for whom it held huge cultural importance, as a source of food, transportation and community. This is in fact not the first time it has been renamed – European cartographers named it ‘Lac de Saint-Louis’ when first discovering it. Then, it was a way for colonisers to both orient themselves in the land, as well as to claim ownership. Now? That same colonial thinking seems to be taking root. This could therefore be a furthering of Trump’s ‘51st state’ goal, using geographical names to assert dominance over its neighbour, or it could be indicative of something else: toponymic narcissism.
Outside of naming places ‘America’, Trump has both historically as a business owner and more recently as President, had a tendency to name places after himself – in a way that Rose-Redwood categorised as ‘toponymic narcissism’. From a boulevard in Florida, Dulles International Airport, to the JFK memorial centre, Trump’s obsession with his own name on places at such a scale is clearly more than tactical.
While plastering ‘America’ all over US maps may not continue his own name’s brand, the extent of this project suggests a more narcissistic outlook, as the President later stated, “We have a gulf, and we have a lake. Now all we need is an ocean.” While likely being hyperbolic, a President even joking about claiming an entire ocean for his country is certainly symptomatic of what Rose-Redwood described as “a cult of personality around an authoritarian leader … who treats the government and its assets as the personal property of the president himself”.
Demonstrably, the name ‘Lake Ontario’ and these new changes come with a deeper meaning. The name carries its own history, as do attempts to give it a more palatable European name. Moreso, the power to make these changes is something worth keeping a note of.
Ultimately, we are left with the question: can names shape history? And if they can, through changing names, can those in power shape history?
Lake Ontario – What’s In A Name?
The motivations behind changing place names and how it can be a tool of the powerful.
On 27 August, Trump renamed ‘Lake Ontario’ to ‘Lake America’, a move with few practical impacts, but one rife with symbolism.
While some major companies, such as Apple and Google, have changed the name on their map services (‘Lake America’ for US users, and ‘Lake Ontario (Lake America)’ for others), many, such as MapQuest, have simply refused to make any changes whatsoever. The importance of this executive order therefore lies not in any practical impacts, but in what it represents: the continuation of several worrying patterns in American politics.
Many will have noticed that this order came only six days after trade talks between the US and Canada collapsed, with both sides claiming that the other made 11th-hour changes to the agreement. As a result, Trump had already announced new 50% tariffs on Canada, kickstarting a trade war that is already deeply unpopular with both Canadians and Americans. As per usual, it seems that the President, when not getting what he wants, chooses the most provocative response.
As put by Reuben Rose-Redwood (a Canadian expert in human geography and place-naming studies), renaming Lake Ontario is merely an attempt to “rage-bait a U.S. ally into submission.” A very similar thing was done when changing the ‘Gulf of Mexico’ to the ‘Gulf of America’. It is meant to provoke anger and create discourse among individuals, while also sending a message to the international community. Derek Alderman described this as a move “to exert some advantage or strength in the trade war with Canada.” Alongside Trump’s regular threats to make Canada the ‘51st state’, this projects a starkly non-cooperative and even authoritarian image to the rest of the world.
At both a national and international level, this also demonstrates Trump’s power as an Executive. Since his electoral win in 2024, we have seen him take advantage of the executive order, creating policies without any political pushback. This is no exception. Rose-Redwood pointed out how naming of this type would usually require the involvement of both countries involved, with an extensive consultation. Instead, all this took was one executive order.
Even more recently, we have seen the US being the only country to reject the ‘Equal Earth Projection’ map at the UN, which shows countries with more accurate sizing. Notably, this projection shows Africa as much larger than on the currently used Mercator map. Combined with this new stint of renaming places at a purely national level, should there be fear that the American map now more closely resembles ideology than reality? And should Presidential power be able to shape a truth that is otherwise agreed upon internationally?
Lake Ontario’s name dates back at least 400 years, from an Iroquoian word given to it by the Wendat people, meaning ‘Great Lake’. It was given by a group for whom it held huge cultural importance, as a source of food, transportation and community. This is in fact not the first time it has been renamed – European cartographers named it ‘Lac de Saint-Louis’ when first discovering it. Then, it was a way for colonisers to both orient themselves in the land, as well as to claim ownership. Now? That same colonial thinking seems to be taking root. This could therefore be a furthering of Trump’s ‘51st state’ goal, using geographical names to assert dominance over its neighbour, or it could be indicative of something else: toponymic narcissism.
Outside of naming places ‘America’, Trump has both historically as a business owner and more recently as President, had a tendency to name places after himself – in a way that Rose-Redwood categorised as ‘toponymic narcissism’. From a boulevard in Florida, Dulles International Airport, to the JFK memorial centre, Trump’s obsession with his own name on places at such a scale is clearly more than tactical.
While plastering ‘America’ all over US maps may not continue his own name’s brand, the extent of this project suggests a more narcissistic outlook, as the President later stated, “We have a gulf, and we have a lake. Now all we need is an ocean.” While likely being hyperbolic, a President even joking about claiming an entire ocean for his country is certainly symptomatic of what Rose-Redwood described as “a cult of personality around an authoritarian leader … who treats the government and its assets as the personal property of the president himself”.
Demonstrably, the name ‘Lake Ontario’ and these new changes come with a deeper meaning. The name carries its own history, as do attempts to give it a more palatable European name. Moreso, the power to make these changes is something worth keeping a note of.
Ultimately, we are left with the question: can names shape history? And if they can, through changing names, can those in power shape history?
Author
Glasgow University Student Left Society Publishes Letter Demanding “Senior Management Starts Working With The University Community”
A Volunteer’s Insight into Glasgow 2026 Commonwealth Games
The most hated team in basketball