Is Wonka’s The Golden Ticket continuing the exploitative nature of competition reality television?
Roald Dahl’s novel, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, has a clear message: it is a warning to audiences against greed and selfishness. In both renditions of the story, kindness and virtue are rewarded while bad behaviour and the desire for more are harshly punished. In Netflix’s Wonka’s The Golden Ticket (2026), the story is loosely recreated as a game show where contestants compete in a series of challenges to win a massive cash prize of $3m. The controversy begins with the competition format of the show, which inherently rewards the people who are most hungry for the prize, sacrificing and backstabbing whenever they deem necessary. This directly contradicts the novel’s message, turning a story about the cost of wanting too much into a game where the prize is real. The appetite for more is no longer the thing being warned against; instead, it is the entire point of the game.
The show is committed to recreating the world of the 1971 film as the set is complete with a real chocolate river and Rusty Goffe, reprising his role as an Oompa Loompa. However, a further step was taken for the character of Willy Wonka as there is no physical presenter, but instead, the disembodied voice of the late Gene Wilder, recreated using AI to guide the contestants through challenges. Although this was authorised by Wilder’s estate, it still understandably raises a few eyebrows. In the name of tribute or continuity, this synthetic voice has potentially taken the place of a paid performer. It raises questions of who can authorise a likeness such as this, and where the boundaries are drawn to prevent this voice from being used for unrelated projects with different intentions.
Netflix’s other new high-stakes competition show, Squid Game: The Challenge (2023-), has a similar problem to that of Wonka’s The Golden Ticket; it inverts the message that the original was trying to get across. In the original Squid Game (2021-2025), it is revealed that the deadly challenges competed in by the poor to win a large sum of money were purely for the entertainment of ultra-rich clients in a takedown of class systems. The spinoff plays into this directly, as viewers watch money-desperate contestants battle each other for the cash prize of nearly $5m.
The ethics of this show, along with Amazon Prime’s Beast Games (2024-) where 1000 contestants competed for $5m, were widely questioned, as the promise of money is used to lure people into sacrificing their dignity for the sake of entertainment. Player 215 of Squid games: The Challenge described a ‘Red Light, Green Light’ challenge, where they were required to stand in the hypothermic conditions of a hanger for seven hours as “very, very taxing.” Similarly, the creators of Beast Games are now facing a lawsuit in which contestants allege, claiming contestants were denied privacy, outside contact, and lacked hygiene products. Despite this, the show remained in Prime’s top 10 for over nine weeks.
The humiliation of contestants for the entertainment of viewers is shared by Wonka’s The Golden Ticket. In one instance, players had to take part in the potentially dangerous task of running up a slippery slope to save their partners; they are shown flailing and falling over which is clearly meant to give viewers a laugh. After a separate task, one contestant was threatening to regurgitate their samples of the chocolate river, and it is expressed by the contestants how “twisted” and “confusing” the challenges are.
The stark similarities between the Wonka spinoff and these other competition spinoffs make it clear that they share the same ethical questions. What initially appears to be a family-friendly magical recreation of a childhood favourite is actually a morally and physically punishing game with real stakes. The competition format fosters a sense of betrayal and humiliation amongst contestants – exploiting them to entertain viewers and make money for streaming platforms – whilst ignoring the heartfelt message of the original story.
Image Credit: Netflix

